Benny's (Formerly Joe Benny’s) Menu

House-made beef and pork meatballs simmered in our signature sauce, topped with creamy burrata, and served with three pieces of fresh bread for the perfect bite.

Our take on a classic, featuring house-made eggplant balls simmered in our signature sauce, topped with creamy burrata, and served with three pieces of fresh bread for the perfect bite.

Lightly fried calamari tossed with diced long hot peppers, served with fresh lemon and house-made sauce for dipping.

Thinly sliced beef, rolled and stuffed with mozzarella, herbed breadcrumbs, and garlic, lightly seared and served over a bed of fresh arugula with a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil.

Sliced beef tenderloin on baguette with garlic-herbed cheese, caramelized onions, and mushroom.

Three crispy risotto balls stuffed with tomato sauce, peas, and stracciatella cheese.

Crisp romaine tossed with house-made Caesar dressing, topped with focaccia croutons, Asiago, Parmigiano, and tangy pickled peppers.

Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, burrata, basil, pistachios & basil-infused olive oil.

Romaine, mixed greens, radicchio, cranberries, fennel, apples and shaved parmigiano with apple cider vinaigrette.

Thick crunchy fries tossed with parsely and Parmigiano

Charred and tender broccolini sautéed with garlic and olive oil, finished with a touch of lemon.

Slow-cooked cornmeal blended with cheese, served with our house red sauce.

Your choice of buttered noodles or tossed with our house red sauce.

Tomato, cucumber, and red onion, tossed in a light vinaigrette.

Creamy Yukon gold potatoes whipped with fresh garlic.

Creamy arborio rice slowly cooked with rich chicken stock and infused with saffron, finished with parmigiano and a touch of butter.

A rich, creamy pistachio sauce with garlic, basil, and fennel sausage.

Classic chitarra pasta tossed in our house-made sauce, topped with Parmigiano and famous Meatballs!

Spaghetti– Classic chitarra pasta tossed in our house-made sauce, topped with Parmigiano

Handcrafted by the legendary Velleggia’s of Little Italy, stuffed with ricotta, topped with sauce and Parmigiano.

Silky ravioli in brown butter sage sauce.

Served two ways: -Fried cutlet with side salad and fries -"Parm' style fried, mozzarella, sauce with a side of pasta

Tender Linguini tossed with Shrimp and Lump Crab in an Old Bay cream sauce.

20oz Ribeye steak grilled to your liking, served with your choice of two sides.

Five jumbo grilled prawns with your choice of two sides.

Five 3oz Lolly Pop Chops, roasted garlic gremolata, served with your choice of two sides.

Casarecce with tomatoes, garlic, olives, capers, anchovies & roasted eggplant

Five delicate cream puffs smothered with luscious Pistachio mousse, topped with Pistachio Crumble. It’s Delicious.

Stay cozy and rep Benny’s in style with our “Best Balls on the Block” hoodie! Soft, warm, and packed with personality, this hoodie is perfect for meatball lovers and anyone who knows where to find the Best Balls on the Block! Whether you’re layering up for a chilly night or just making a bold statement, this hoodie has you covered—literally.

Take home the bold, rich flavors of Benny’s with our 32 oz jar of homemade sauce—crafted with love, tradition, and a whole lotta Italian passion. Slow-simmered to perfection with the finest ingredients, this sauce is ready to take your pasta, meatballs, and Sunday dinners to the next level. And let’s settle this once and for all… “It’s sauce, not gravy!” So grab a jar, skip the argument, and taste what real Italian flavor is all about. ✔ Made with high-quality, fresh ingredients ✔ No preservatives—just pure, delicious sauce ✔ Perfect for pasta, pizza, or straight from the spoon (we won’t judge) Stock up now—because one jar is never enough!

You asked, we delivered—Joe Benny’s famous meatballs, now frozen and vacuum-sealed for maximum freshness! Our “Frozen Ballsack” comes packed with 12 of our legendary, flavor-packed meatballs, made just like we do in-house. Whether you’re stocking up for a quick weeknight dinner or planning a feast, these bad boys are ready when you are. Just heat, sauce ‘em up, and enjoy the Best Balls on the Block—anytime, anywhere. ✔ Authentic Italian meatballs, made from scratch ✔ Vacuum-sealed for peak freshness ✔ Easy to heat & serve—just add sauce! Grab a Frozen Ballsack today and keep your freezer stocked with the good stuff!

Because great meatballs deserve great sauce! Get the best of Benny’s with this legendary combo—a 32oz jar of our homemade sauce and a Frozen Ballsack packed with 12 of our famous meatballs, vacuum-sealed for freshness. Whether you’re cooking for the family, meal-prepping, or just making sure your freezer is stocked with the good stuff, this combo brings authentic Italian flavor straight to your kitchen. ✔ 12 scratch-made, flavor-packed meatballs ✔ 32oz of our slow-simmered, homemade sauce ✔ Vacuum-sealed & ready to heat, sauce, and serve And don’t forget… “It’s sauce, not gravy!” Grab your Balls & Sauce Combo today and taste what everyone’s talking about!

Just mozzarella and our signature sauce—nothing more, nothing less.

Red Sauce, Mozzarella, Meatball, Sausage, Pepperoni

White Garlic Sauce, Mozzarella, Diced Onion, Mushroom, Peppers, Tomato

White Garlic Sauce, Mozzarella, Crispy Prosciutto, Arugula, Balsamic

A bold Italian classic with mortadella, salami, and prosciutto cotto, layered with melted Asiago and mozzarella, topped with tomato, arugula, red onion, pickled peppers, and a drizzle of balsamic.

Our take on the ultimate meatball sub—house-made meatballs smothered in sauce, topped with creamy burrata and melted mozzarella.

Crispy fried chicken cutlet covered in our signature sauce, topped with burrata and melted mozzarella for the perfect bite.

A fresh and flavorful combination of tomato, red onion, arugula, and basil, drizzled with olive oil and balsamic for a simple yet delicious Italian classic.